News >> Browse Articles >> Careers
News >> Browse Articles >> Scandals
Wisconsin Nurse Laid Off Mid-Surgery
The Wisconsin State Journal
April 14, 2009
A Dean Health System manager removed a nurse from a minor surgical procedure last week — in violation of medical protocol — in order to lay her off, a spokesman for the company confirmed Monday.
The abrupt removal, which spokesman Paul Pitas said posed no danger to the patient, came after the Madison-based health-care provider announced Wednesday that it planned to “immediately” lay off 90 employees.
Pitas, director of corporate communications, labeled the action “clearly … an error in judgment on the part of the manager conducting the layoff.” He declined to name the manager but described her as “an otherwise good employe with more than 30 years of nursing experience who made a regrettable decision.”
“This person is very upset and is extremely remorseful over this,” Pitas said, adding that the layoffs created “extraordinary circumstances.”
Pitas said the incident occurred at Dean’s West Clinic at 752 N. High Point Road on Wednesday or Thursday as employees were notified of the job cuts.
He declined to name the employees involved or what type of procedure the nurse was assisting in when she was summoned from her duties and terminated.
“There was a period of time in which an RN was not present during the procedure,” Pitas said. “While there were other clinical staff present, including a physician, the absence of an RN goes against established patient-care procedures at Dean Health System.”
He added that the patient, whose name is protected by patient confidentiality laws, is “doing fine.”
“We can tell you the physician who performed the procedure reports it went as expected,” he said.
dannymreed
6 months ago
14 comments
I noticed.
dannymreed
7 months ago
14 comments
The money managers are telling healthcare professionals what they can and cannot do. Nothing new about that. Apparently the person was not a threat to self or others at the time. What authority did the person have to physically remove someone in the middle of a procedure? This woman has some serious questions she is accountable to answer. The answer is always, "Because I can."
JCHaftlRNBSN
7 months ago
4 comments
I absolutely agree with doctorwww. Well said. I was fired years ago (for something silly and non-clinical). while working in an ER treating an MI in progress. The "nurse manager" pulled me away from the bedside as we were working frantically to stabilize the patient. I would have quit for her stupidity alone....I had no idea I could file a complaint to the State Board. This "manager" put the patient at risk, not only leaving the ER short staffed, but definitely affected the mind set of the MDs and RNs working on this patient, they all lost their focus and concentration on the patient. I'm now out of hospital nursing and no one could EVER pay me enough to return to such an abusive job. Most so-called "Nurse Managers" are more concerned with budgets, not the well-being of patients or staff. I've had managers who could not start IVs, put in Foley caths, or perform even basic ER nursing skills. I've had colleagues tell these types of managers (who are grossly overpaid) to leave the ER because they cannot perform, or keep up on a busy weekend, and are a disruption to the staff. I strongly suggest that the State Boards mandate a minimum of an MSN or clinical Doctoral degree for those in management. We need to return Medicine and Nursing back to the Academics!!!!!!
mesima
7 months ago
18 comments
I am not surprised. It is all about the money.
dawniebaby777At43
7 months ago
8 comments
SOMETIMES, REMEMER THIS, RULES ARE RULES, AND THERE ARE SOME EXCEPTIONS TO THOSE RULES WHEN NEED BE, WHATEVER HAPPENED TO COMPASSION, HELLO?
doctorwww
7 months ago
2 comments
Unprofessional, not in the best interests of the patient, and probably unethical. I think that a complaint to the Wisconsin Medical Examining Board and Nursing Examining Board/Department of Professional Regulation should be filed immediately. The manager who agreed to carry out this "order of execution" should be fired and the Dean" Health System", to use the term extremely loosely, should be placed under severe sanctions with extreme oversight by a multidisciplinary Board of Overseers. It boggles the mind that such unprofessional conduct would go unpunished by the Wisconsin Department of Professional Regulation. And just whom does Paul Pitas think that he is bulls....ing? Have you no shame?
ldia
7 months ago
2 comments
The first rule of patient care is, "do no harm." The well being of the patient is the highest priority. Clearly ,any person working in healthcare management, should have enough common sense to know, an employee termination should happen after surgery is completed. RN's often observe things overlooked by doctors which is one of the reasons they are utilized in healthcare procedures. What if suddenly the patient had a crisis such as a drop in blood pressure, allergic reaction, or went into cardiac arrest. It can happen in routine procedures and that is why there are established protocols to handle unexpected events. A manager who is so focused on the bottom line, that she overlooks the well being of the patient, and treats her colleague in such an unprofessional manner, does not have my confidence. I do not care how many years of experience she has accumulated this is poor healthtcare procedure and poor management. If the administration is planning to lay off 90 people, training management regarding proper procedures for terminatio,n should be part of the lay off plan. With this kind of publicity, they may be laying off more workers, after people realize this organization does not have their priorities in order.
Moontears71
7 months ago
4 comments
Im not surprised. Anymore it is about the dollar and not always about patient care .'
mbatm
7 months ago
2 comments
wow - this is where major errors occur - shame on them
psylocke
7 months ago
4 comments
Truly disgraceful. Give the RN her job back and fired the manager.
cpkranky
7 months ago
2 comments
I am with you RMT..to pull a nurse from a case to "lay her off" could have waited till the end of the day. Not during a procedure! Would never consider working for a facility that treated staff so unprofessionally!
RMT_
7 months ago
2 comments
The so-called "Manager" is the one who needed to be let go.
telmagazio
7 months ago
44 comments
Very unprofessional. It's unbelievable.
OTOldie
7 months ago
68 comments
Wow. How unprofessional.