News >> Browse Articles >> Healthcare Reform

Rate

Fact Check: A Closer Look at Obama's Healthcare Address

Associated Press/AP Online

September 10, 2009



President Barack Obama used only-in-Washington accounting Wednesday when he promised to overhaul the nation’s health care system without adding “one dime” to the deficit. By conventional arithmetic, Democratic plans would drive up the deficit by billions of dollars.

The president’s speech to Congress contained a variety of oversimplifications and omissions in laying out what he wants to do about health insurance.

A look at some of Obama’s claims and how they square with the facts of the fuller story.

Obama’s First Claim >>


Rate
  • Photo_user_blank_big

    edrnpaul

    about 1 month ago

    8 comments

    The race card can effectively be played because the disease of political correctness has a stranglehold on us all. No one wants to be labeled as a racist so when the claim is made, most of us just immediately shut up. Truth is, I don't care what color or sex the President is, but I cannot support Obama's policies of taking away from the producers and giving to the non producers of the country. True, some are non producers because they aren't capable, and they should be taken care of. But many more simply choose not to contribute to society. They have been raised to feel that they are entitled to what I have worked hard to earn. They are society's parasites. Obama care simply adds to the entitlement mentality. Well guess what, I don't feel they are entitled to a damn thing that I earn.

    Can any government run healthcare proponents give me any example of any program that government runs that is not full of waste, fraud and corruption?

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    jfasic

    about 1 month ago

    2 comments

    Why is any and all opposition to Obama's trend toward Socialism in healthcare (which has been tried often and has never been successful) dubbed "racist?"

    Are we really that ignorant as a society?

    It is funny to read about the "possibility" of increasing deficit-spending, when the deficit has increased over the past 9 months at the fastest rate in history.

    The government makes healthcare more expensive. Less government= more efficiency= better care

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    1954nurse

    2 months ago

    10 comments

    Why is it so difficult for all of Americans to embrace the advice and help of this President? I hope it has nothing to do with the color of his skin. Let's go back now wasn't it the black woman who cared for your white children and wasn't it the black man who plowed you field yielding you a bountiful harvest every season and there was no lack. So it behooves me that black people has been more of an asset to your existence than the pain you cry about. We did not harm you then although you thought your beating us kept us in subjection and we do you no harm now. Let's embrace one another and put all hatred aside and strive from the greater good in human kind.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    1954nurse

    2 months ago

    10 comments

    I think it is a good idea get on top of it before it runs a muck like the real-estate companies did. No one will appreciate it but isn't just like children who hate their vegetables.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    1954nurse

    2 months ago

    10 comments

    President Obama is correct, the United States is so wasteful and if you don't believe me take a trip to the nearest public school during breakfast and lunch time and look at the trash bags of food they throw out daily. Go to the nursing homes and look at the wast from band-aids, pills not given to linen not used but thrown back in the hamper to be washed again. If you ever go into the hospital look in the medication room are these adults that leave so much trash behind and unused IV fluids and IV lines. On your job how much waste do you see on a daily basis, how about that extra paper do you just throw it in the trash? We want to balme everyone but that picture in the mirror. Yeah , you!

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    1954nurse

    2 months ago

    10 comments

    How many people stay fixed on a job most people work an average of 2 1/2 jobs. Now for injuries on the job no one want to take responsibility for this monster. I worked in an Emergency Room as a RN and injured my knee. They kept me off work with no pay until I said I would not file for workman comp and because I was per diem I had to buy my own insurance who after having my knee repaired said it was a pre-existing condition and they would not pay for it. Now here I am 9 months later no job and everyone that has one is complaining. No, I do not have insurance/

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    1954nurse

    2 months ago

    10 comments

    Is this why so many Senators have illegal immigrants working for them as nannies and house keepers? What hypocrites or are we seeing slavery in this 21 century that no one want to relate to.

  • Pompei_guy_max50

    PhillyXTech

    2 months ago

    388 comments

    The article does begin by restating a traditional conservative calculation method of taking the face value price of something and not adding in the savings.

    IE.

    $(-100) - $100=$(-200) loss.

    rather than the true equation:

    $(-100) - $100 + $100,000(savings)= $99,800 gain.

    Republicans never look at the long term, because their entire election platforms are based on short term fears rather than solving big social problems that cost us billions and billions of dollars.

    They would rather narrow their sites on more easily definable numbers that in the long run mean nothing than take on the immense, and often unpopular tasks of bringing our runnaway budget back in line, (not just with cutting programs that don't take up that much of the budget anyway, but with raising taxes despite it being unpopular, and with curbing appetites in the country as a whole that lead to economic ruin... AKA why the hell did we do away with all of the banking regulations and then act all suprised when the markets collapsed?).

    Obama is offering a long term solution. If we don't take it, the portions of our country that already resemble third world nations will only continue to grow. And don't even kid yourself, they do emphatically exist.

    Theodore Kazinsky's shack was luxurious compaired with some of the accomidations I've seen our fellow Americans living in, and they not by choice.

    The more we force our citizens to bicker over the smallest portion of the economy left after the massive waste that gigantic megacorporations acrue as pure profit, the worse off we all become.

    When a plane is falling out of the sky, "pull up," is not oversimplification, it's just stating the obvious.

  • Otoldie_max50

    OTOldie

    2 months ago

    68 comments

    I would disagree that the article is opinionated with little value. I thought there were some good quotes and figures in there. Yes, it's not the most in-depth article ever, but given the timeliness of it, I think it answers some good questions... especially for folks who haven't been following the healthcare debate as closely as they admit/would want.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    johnbennett

    2 months ago

    2 comments

    This fact check contained very limited insight or fact checks. Much more of an opinion/editorial article with little value.

  • Img_0512_-_copy_max50

    Tinkerbell1969

    2 months ago

    10 comments

    Employers might be able to change their health plans if there isn't a provision in the bill that makes doing so illegal. Small businesses should not be forced into this but large companies and corporations can certainly assist their employees in footing the bill for their health plan.

  • Img_0512_-_copy_max50

    Tinkerbell1969

    2 months ago

    10 comments

    He would be the biggest of fools if he signed a bill that increased the deficit after stating so in his speech. As stated, there is no final plan YET and the way things are going we may not get one. Let us wait and see what they offer us before we even try to predict the outcome.